Another Exercise In Simple Arithmetic: The Federal Budget
/A long-time focus of this blog has been the simple arithmetic that shows why an electrical grid powered only by wind and sun can never fully work. Among dozens of my posts on this subject, one of the better summaries can be found in this one from November 2023 at the time of the COP 28 UN climate meeting in Dubai.
And yet despite the simple nature of the calculations at issue, huge numbers of dedicated adherents to the climate cult march forward pursuing an energy transition utopia that can’t possibly happen. As I wrote incredulously in that 2023 post:
The COP 28 climate confab opened today in Dubai. Some 70,000 true believers in the energy transition are said to be gathering. And not one of them appears to be either willing or able to do the simple arithmetic that shows that this can’t possibly work.
Here now three years later, with hundreds of billions more dollars wasted and the energy transition no closer to happening, the number of participants at this year’s ongoing COP 31 conference in Turkey is said to be 102,000.
And that’s only about the climate/energy utopia. Meanwhile the phenomenon of failing to apply the most basic reality checks to grand utopian schemes has been metastasizing everywhere. At one time, when big new government programs got proposed, the proponents were expected to address the questions of “how much is this going to cost?” and “how are we going to pay for it?” Those days are now long gone.
Let’s look at where we are on the U.S. federal budget. This is perhaps an order of magnitude (10x) larger than the mere energy transition fiasco.
In the 2026 fiscal year just ended on September 30, the Congressional Budget Office provides the following figures: total federal spending was about $7.4 trillion, and revenues were about $5.4 trillion, leaving a deficit of about $2 trillion. With GDP of about $33 trillion, the $2 trillion deficit is about 6%. Even with robust GDP growth (3.4% in the latest quarter), a deficit of 6% of GDP means that the national debt grows rapidly as a percent of GDP, which in turn means that interest costs continually rise both in absolute terms and as a share of the budget, thus crowding out other potential expenditures.
In the spending category for FY 2026, the big numbers were: Social Security $1.5 trillion; Medicare $1.3 trillion; Medicaid $0.7 trillion (federal share only); defense just under $1.0 trillion; and interest on the publicly-held debt just over $1.0 trillion. Those five categories add up to about $5.5 trillion — more than all revenues. Everything else comes to about $1.9 trillion.
A huge and rarely mentioned issue is that the big “entitlements” grow on autopilot, and almost always at rates significantly faster than the rate of economic growth. That’s how they have gotten to be such huge percentages of the budget without major changes in policy or benefit formulas. Thus, compared to the most recent (and very strong) GDP growth rate of 3.4%, here were the growth rates of the big entitlements for FY 2026 over FY 2025: Social Security spending increased by $83 billion over prior spending of $1.42 billion, or 5.8%; Medicare spending increased by $75 billion over prior spending of $1.25 trillion, or 6.1%; and Medicaid spending increased by about $51 billion over prior spending of $649 billion, or 7.9%. These rates of growth continue long-term rates for all three programs well above the rate of economic growth. For example, Medicare spending was $242 billion in 2001, going to $1.5 trillion in 2026, for a compound rate of growth of 7.6%; and federal Medicaid spending was about $130 billion in 2001, going to $700 billion in 2026, for a compound rate of growth of 6.97%. The compound rate of growth of the GDP over the same period (in comparable non-inflation-adjusted numbers) was about 4.65%.
I would say that it is impossible to look at these numbers without concluding that the United States has a big problem of spending on entitlements, and needs to figure out a way to get the entitlement spending into line with the size of the economy before the entitlements swallow the whole thing and completely impoverish the people.
As other evidence that the entitlements need some serious belt-tightening, we have the fact that the so-called trust fund for Social Security is running out, and quite rapidly. While the statutory “trust fund” concept may be arbitrary and not very meaningful, it is meaningful that the dedicated revenues of the Social Security system fall farther and farther short of the expenditures, with the negatives increasing year by year. This year’s deficit is about $221 billion, up from only $160 billion last year; next year, the projected deficit will be $275 billion.
So then, the big debate this political season would have to be about ways to address these very huge issues before they become crises. Right? But instead it was just the opposite: The winning Democrats not only completely avoided any mention of the unsustainable situation with current entitlements, but also campaigned on vast increases in spending, including both existing and new entitlements, with barely a mention of how that would be paid for other than that the money would come from someone other than you (i.e., “the rich”).
At the New York Sun, they have a round-up today under the headline “Democrats’ Post-Election Agenda: A Sweeping Wish List of Government Spending.” (behind paywall). The list is almost endless. Start with healthcare:
The centerpiece of the Democratic spending push is healthcare — namely, restoring Medicaid funding and extending Affordable Care Act subsidies. House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries laid out the stakes in a November 4 manifesto: “During the first 100 days, House Democrats must act to reverse the Medicaid cuts, restore SNAP funding, extend the Affordable Care Act tax credits, . . .”
Jeffries there doesn’t even mention Medicare for All, which was a centerpiece of dozens if not hundreds of victorious Democratic campaigns. The “Medicaid cuts” that he does mention were eligibility restrictions contained in the OBBB — things like work requirements and eligibility redeterminations. These were not cuts to spending at all, but only would slow the ongoing growth somewhat, although even in a best case not likely to a level as low as overall GDP growth.
And here from the Sun are a few more examples of proposed major spending increases put forth by various Democrats:
Progressives want to go even further. Congresswomen Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Terri Sewell are pushing Mr. Jeffries to expand Medicare to cover dental, vision, and hearing, along with medical debt relief and restored funding for the National Institutes of Health. . . . The spending ambitions don’t stop there. Illinois Governor JB Pritzker, viewed as a possible 2028 presidential contender, released a roughly 200-point policy platform calling for restored government jobs at Health and Human Services and the Department of Education, more infrastructure spending, and expanded housing and food assistance funding. . . . Independent Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont has pushed an even bolder vision, calling for $12,000 payments to working-class families of four, free public university tuition, universal childcare, expanded Medicare eligibility, and a $2,400 annual boost to Social Security benefits.
And it goes on and on from there. To all appearances, the voters now seem to believe that the government credit card is truly infinite. So the only check on this going forward will be actually running out of the other people’s money. If that is so, we have a long, long way to go — and down a road that is very likely to end in tragedy.